Importance of Validating Scientific Citations - Topic Citations
Every citation has two independent 0-100 scores. The source Reliability score rates the general reliability of the outlet itself, regardless of the specific claim, based on an eight-tier scale running from primary government and international scientific bodies (CDC, WHO, NASA, IPCC) at the top, through peer-reviewed journals, wire services, mainstream science journalism, and advocacy organizations, down to tertiary references like Wikipedia and unverifiable or absent sources at the bottom. The Accuracy score, by contrast, rates how well a specific citation supports topic statements — a citation from an excellent source can score low if misapplied or can score high if it precisely backs up topic statements.
Where a citation is a research paper, Check paper opens our citation checker in a new tab. It confirms the paper exists, flags any retraction, and shows how later research has cited it, using the open research database OpenAlex.
Science Denial Tactics
- Skeptical ScienceReliability score: 74 | Accuracy score: 86
- Skeptical ScienceReliability score: 74 | Accuracy score: 86
- Skeptical ScienceReliability score: 74 | Accuracy score: 85
- Skeptical ScienceReliability score: 74 | Accuracy score: 85
- European Journal of Public HealthReliability score: 86 | Accuracy score: 91
- European Journal of Public HealthReliability score: 86 | Accuracy score: 91
- European Journal of Public HealthReliability score: 86 | Accuracy score: 92
- European Journal of Public HealthReliability score: 86 | Accuracy score: 92
Citing Retracted Research
- JAMA Network OpenReliability score: 94 | Accuracy score: 89 | Check paper
- JAMA Network OpenReliability score: 94 | Accuracy score: 89 | Check paper
- BMJ Global HealthReliability score: 88 | Accuracy score: 91
- BMJ Global HealthReliability score: 88 | Accuracy score: 91
Validating Citations
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)Reliability score: 90 | Accuracy score: 86
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)Reliability score: 90 | Accuracy score: 86
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)Reliability score: 90 | Accuracy score: 88
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)Reliability score: 90 | Accuracy score: 88
- Retraction Watch / CrossrefReliability score: 82 | Accuracy score: 84
- Retraction Watch / CrossrefReliability score: 82 | Accuracy score: 84
AI-Generated Citations
- Scientific ReportsReliability score: 85 | Accuracy score: 94 | Check paper
- Scientific ReportsReliability score: 85 | Accuracy score: 94 | Check paper
- CureusReliability score: 65 | Accuracy score: 82 | Check paper
- CureusReliability score: 65 | Accuracy score: 82 | Check paper
Misrepresented Findings
- BMJReliability score: 92 | Accuracy score: 95 | Check paper
- BMJReliability score: 92 | Accuracy score: 95 | Check paper
Retractions and Misconduct
- Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)Reliability score: 92 | Accuracy score: 94 | Check paper
- Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)Reliability score: 92 | Accuracy score: 94 | Check paper
Purpose of Citations
- PeerJReliability score: 88 | Accuracy score: 90
- PeerJReliability score: 88 | Accuracy score: 90
Secondary Sources
- Complex SystemsReliability score: 78 | Accuracy score: 80
- Complex SystemsReliability score: 78 | Accuracy score: 80
Inaccurate Citations
- Research Integrity and Peer ReviewReliability score: 90 | Accuracy score: 93 | Check paper
- Research Integrity and Peer ReviewReliability score: 90 | Accuracy score: 93 | Check paper
